New York Mills Homes for Sale

New York Mills, located in Otter Tail County, Minnesota, is a charming city that offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern amenities. With a population of around 1,200 residents, this tight-knit community provides a welcoming and friendly atmosphere.

For those looking to settle down in New York Mills, there is a variety of homes for sale that cater to different budgets and preferences. Whether you're in the market for a cozy single-family home, a spacious townhouse, or a sprawling country estate, you're sure to find something that suits your needs.

The real estate market in New York Mills offers a range of options, from historic properties with character to newly constructed homes with modern features. Many of the homes for sale boast beautiful landscapes, providing residents with picturesque views of the surrounding natural beauty.

In addition to the available homes, New York Mills offers a range of amenities and attractions. The city is home to a vibrant downtown area, where you can find local shops, restaurants, and cafes. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the numerous parks and recreational areas, perfect for hiking, biking, and enjoying nature.

With its small-town charm, friendly community, and diverse real estate options, New York Mills is an ideal place to call home. Whether you're a first-time buyer or looking to relocate, this city has something to offer everyone. Don't miss out on the opportunity to find your dream home in this wonderful Minnesota city.

Newest New York Mills Homes for Sale

$339,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7145978 MLS

Premier location! Move-in-ready 4 bedroom 3 Bath 1987 Dynamic Home on a corner lot next to the baseball and football fields. Features updated Andersen windows, LP siding, shingles, attached and detached garages, mature trees, and apple trees. A great combination of location, updates, and convenience!

399 Lund Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of New Horizons Realty Of Perham.

$100,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7142440 MLS

Looking for an affordable home, investment property, or a place to downsize? This cozy 1-bedroom, 1-bath home offers comfortable living in a convenient New York Mills location, right next to the park! The main level features a functional living space, kitchen, bathroom and laundry, while the upstairs provides a private bedroom. The basement offers additional storage space along with a sauna—perfect for relaxing at the end of the day. Outside, you'll appreciate the detached 2-stall garage, providing plenty of room for vehicles and storage. With the park right outside your door and the amenities of New York Mills close by, this home is a great opportunity to enjoy small-town living with plenty of convenience.

128 Smith Avenue, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Centennial Realty.

$190,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7142954 MLS

Welcome Home Just Outside New York Mills, Minnesota Country charm meets everyday convenience in this inviting 3-bedroom, 1½-bath farm-style home. Set just outside of town, this property offers the perfect balance — close enough for easy access to local amenities, yet private enough to feel like a true escape from it all. The classic farmhouse character shines throughout, offering warmth and space for comfortable, relaxed living. Adding even more value, a barn on the property provides endless possibilities — perfect for a workshop, extra storage, or a dream woodworking space for hobbyists and craftsmen alike. Whether you're looking to slow down, spread out, or simply enjoy a little more space and privacy, this property offers a rare opportunity to have the best of both worlds. Country living starts here.

52473 County Highway 14, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty.

$225,222

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7093380 MLS

Move In Ready! 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home nestled in the heart of New York Mills! Ideally located just blocks from City Hall, the school, downtown businesses, restaurants, parks, and other local amenities, this property offers the convenience of in-town living while embracing the warmth and character of a classic home. Built in 1920, this well-maintained home blends timeless charm with valuable updates. A new furnace installed in 2026 provides efficient comfort during Minnesota winters, while the roof on the detached two-stall garage was replaced in 2023, offering added peace of mind. The low-maintenance vinyl siding and central air conditioning make everyday living even more enjoyable. Step inside to discover inviting living spaces filled with natural light and character. The cozy gas fireplace creates the perfect gathering place for family and friends, while the functional layout offers three comfortable bedrooms and up graded bathrooms. Outside, you’ll appreciate the spacious wood deck, ideal for grilling, entertaining, or relaxing after a long day. The detached two-stall garage provides excellent space for vehicles, tools, toys, and additional storage. Location is everything, and this home delivers. Enjoy being within walking distance of schools, shopping, dining, churches, community events, and everything that makes New York Mills such a wonderful place to call home.

118 Tousley Avenue N, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Boll Realty.

$549,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7132208 MLS

Level 117' of pristine shoreline on Big Pine Lake with stunning sunset views and a sandy-bottom waterfront. This completely remodeled true craftsman cabin blends rustic charm with modern comfort, quiet and efficient spray-foam insulation. Enjoy in-floor heat, mini-split cooling, and beautiful polished concrete floors, all just steps from the water. The large lot offers plenty of room to expand, including the opportunity to add a garage. Easy year-round access makes this the perfect lake home in every season. Big Pine Lake spans approximately 4,775 acres and is known scenic boating, and outstanding fishing. A rare opportunity to own a beautifully updated lakeside cabin where rustic character meets quality modern construction.

42911 County Highway 53, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of New Horizons Realty Of Perham.

$265,500

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7121876 MLS

Beautiful Country Living on 2 Wooded Acres! Nestled on 2 private wooded acres, this inviting 2 bedroom home offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy and potential. The spacious kitchen provides plenty of room for cooking and gathering, while the adjoining dining room is ideal for family meals and entertaining. Relax year round in the sun room featuring a cozy fireplace, or step outside to the large deck with built in seating that overlooks the beautifully landscaped yard filled with mature trees and colorful perennial beds. The main floor laundry offers flexibility and could serve as a third bedroom, office or hobby space. Laundry hookups in lower level. The lower level is a blank slate to finish as desired, but does have an electric sauna ready for the cold winter months. Rounding it out is an attached garage, paved driveway, and a peaceful setting along a tarred road. Don't miss this opportunity to make this private retreat your own.

57773 County Highway 56, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Centennial Realty.

$474,900

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7113231 MLS

Enjoy the privacy of country living with this spacious 5-bedroom, 2-bath home located on 7 scenic acres. The upper level is set up well for comfortable living and entertaining, with the large open floor plan filled with natural light. The lower features a walk out basement as well as in floor heat and large family room. Outside, you'll find everything you need for work, hobbies, and storage with a heated 30' x 48' shop and a large 48' x 48' pole shed. A welcoming circle driveway adds convenience along with tons of concrete to add great curb appeal and flexibility. There will also be a new septic installed prior to closing or escrowed. Whether you're looking for room to grow, space for your toys, or simply a quiet place to call home, this property offers endless possibilities. Schedule your private showing today!

57890 425th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Hinkle Realty.

$533,200

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7101641 MLS

Escape to the country with this beautiful home nestled on 10 scenic acres, where rustic charm meets comfortable living. When you step inside you are met with stunning woodwork, and warm character and details throughout. Wood flooring, trim and design includes redwood, hickory, white oak, pine and more! The spacious kitchen offers an abundance of cabinets and workspace and is open to the dining room and living room for seamless entertaining. The main floor features a private primary bedroom with an en-suite bath. With 3 bedrooms and 3 baths, there is plenty of space for family and guests. The bonus room in the lower level is great for gaming, office or crafts. The lower level walk out provides a family room, office, bath, sewing/craft room. Step outside and enjoy the peaceful setting with mature trees, colorful flower beds and a nostalgic barn that adds timeless country appeal. A massive 120x36 shed (4320 sq ft) provides ample space for equipment, recreational vehicles, workshop and storage, is equipped to hook up in-floor heat and a portion was used as a riding arena.. The wrap around deck provides a gorgeous view and shade during the warm summer nights. There is so much to take in at this property. Be prepared to be impressed! Lower level has been equipped for in-floor heat. See supplement for additional information, updates and upgrades.

51374 330th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Centennial Realty.

$220,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7090533 MLS

Welcome to New York Mills! This beautifully updated 3-bedroom home is ready for you to move right in and call it your own. If you are looking for convenience, comfort, and charm, you couldn't find a better location. Key Features You'll Love: Prime Location: Situated just moments away from local schools, beautiful parks, and a vibrant downtown area. Turn-Key & Fresh: Newly remodeled and freshly painted throughout, making it the perfect match for your lifestyle. Sunlit Living Space: The inviting family room is flooded with bright, natural light—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Elegant Kitchen: Completely remodeled and designed to be as functional as it is beautiful for all your cooking needs. Endless Potential Areas: The unfinished basement currently serves as a highly functional space for laundry, storage, and a wood shop. However, it offers a fantastic blank canvas with the potential to add an extra bedroom or design a second family living area to instantly build equity.

100 Walker Avenue N, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty.

$450,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7094210 MLS

Sprawling 10-Acre Retreat in New York Mills! This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of country privacy and modern living. The heart of the home features a newly remodeled kitchen that flows seamlessly into the dining and family rooms—ideal for everything from casual weeknight dinners to formal family meals. Step out onto the expansive, newly updated back deck, which offers the perfect vantage point for grilling and entertaining friends while overlooking a private backyard teeming with local wildlife. Adding incredible value to this property is a second, mostly finished detached building. Brimming with potential, this versatile space is a blank canvas ready for your final touches—perfect for a home office, studio, guest quarters, or secondary living space. Don’t miss this rare acreage opportunity!

57582 398th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty.

$74,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7038453 MLS

2-bedroom, 1-bath home situated on a 0.34-acre lot in New York Mills. The property offers over 1,000 finished square feet, a detached 1-stall garage, enclosed front porch, and rear mudroom entry. Interior features include hardwood floors along with spacious living and dining areas. Unfinished basement provides additional storage space. City water and sewer services are connected. Convenient in-town location with access to local amenities, schools, and employment centers.

126 Tousley Avenue N, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Gallery of Homes.

$299,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7033664 MLS

RENOVATED COUNTRY HOME WITH WOODS & PASTURE! Discover the perfect blend of Privacy & Modern Comfort with this beautifully Renovated Country Home set on 5.46 Acres just 9 minutes from New York Mills. With 3.75 Acres of Mature Woods & Established Trails winding throughout, the property offers a peaceful, secluded setting ideal for exploring, relaxing, and enjoying the outdoors. The open Pasture area provides excellent potential for a Hobby Farm, complete with a Lean-To Shed already in place. Step inside to find a fully updated home offering 4 Beds, 2 Full Baths, and 3,136 SqFt across two levels. The Beautifully Remodeled Kitchen features All-New Appliances, Cabinetry, a Center Island, and a Walk-In Pantry, creating a functional and inviting space for everyday living & entertaining. The Main Level Owner’s Suite includes a Walk-In Closet, Private Balcony, and an adjacent Bonus Room that would make an excellent home office or flex space. Downstairs, the Full Finished Basement offers a spacious Family Room, 2 Bedrooms, Laundry Room, and a Storage Room with direct access to the attached 14x24 Tuck-Under Garage. Additional Renovation Highlights include All-New Flooring throughout, fully Remodeled Bedrooms & Bathrooms, and a Brand-New Septic installed in 2024. With Modern Updates, Functional Land, and Peaceful Rural Surroundings, this property offers an Ideal Setting to enjoy Country Living with Room to Grow!

51132 340th St, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Jack Chivers Realty.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other this firm are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. Property locations as displayed on any map are best approximations only and exact locations should be independently verified.

Listing data © 2026 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. All rights reserved. By searching, you agree to the EULA.